Save Venice is seeking sponsors for the conservation of Paolo Veronese’s Crucifixion and Carletto Caliari’s Four Angels Bearing the Instruments of the Passion.

*Published sponsorship costs are subject to change due to conservation plan modifications and fluctuations in exchange rates.

Please contact kim@savevenice.org today for more information and the latest cost estimates.

Few paintings convey the emotional drama of the Crucifixion with the intensity found in Paolo Veronese’s canvas for the church of San Nicolò della Lattuga. Executed around 1582, this late masterpiece reveals a striking transformation in the artist’s approach. The luminous color and celebratory grandeur that had long defined Veronese’s art give way to a darker, more restrained visual language, one attuned to grief, contemplation, and spiritual reflection. Created in the wake of that collective trauma, the painting formed part of an ambitious decorative program for the presbytery of San Nicolò della Lattuga devoted to Christ’s ministry, Passion, and the promise of redemption. The ensemble also included four canvases depicting Four Angels Bearing the Instruments of the Passion, works attributed to Veronese’s son, Carlo “Carletto” Caliari.

The origins of San Nicolò della Lattuga stretch back to 1332, when Nicolò Lion, procurator of San Marco, founded the church in gratitude for a miraculous recovery from a grave illness. According to local tradition, the cure came through a remedy made from lettuce—lattuga in Italian—giving the church the distinctive name by which it became known. Nestled behind the Franciscan basilica of Santa Maria Gloriosa dei Frari, San Nicolò della Lattuga occupied a modest but significant place within Venice’s sacred landscape.

In the late 16th century, the church was rebuilt and reconsecrated, culminating in 1582 with an ambitious campaign of decoration entrusted, among others, to Paolo Veronese and his workshop. The presbytery became the focal point of this renewal, its paintings conceived as part of a carefully orchestrated visual program that engaged in dialogue with Titian’s renowned Madonna and Child with Saints, painted between 1522 and 1526 for the high altar and now preserved in the Vatican Pinacoteca. The church was suppressed under Napoleonic rule in 1806 and subsequently demolished; today, its memory survives in Calle San Nicoleto, a narrow alley behind the Frari that marks the area where the building once stood.

Crucifixion

Paolo Veronese’s Crucifixion draws closely on the Gospel of Matthew, whose account of Christ’s death provided artists with some of the most vivid and dramatic imagery of the Passion. The composition opens not in stillness, but in the midst of upheaval. From fractured stone slabs, a foreshortened figure emerges from the tomb. In this startling detail, Veronese gives visual form to Matthew’s words: “The earth quaked, rocks were split, tombs were opened, and the bodies of many saints who had fallen asleep were raised” (27:51–52). Around this miraculous event, terror spreads across the scene. To the left, a group of soldiers reacts in alarm: one flees, another stares speechlessly, and a third instinctively reaches for the hilt of his sword, as if preparing to defend himself against the impossible. On the opposite side, a powerful horse rears in fright as its rider pulls sharply on the reins, struggling to regain control. The entire scene is charged with a sense of sudden disruption, as the natural order gives way before Christ’s death.

Only after this chain of panic does the eye move toward the Crucifixion itself, unfolding in the upper left, where Christ is identified by the mocking inscription “King of the Jews.” From this focal point, Veronese orchestrates the drama along a sweeping diagonal that mirrors both the emotional and theological progression of Matthew’s narrative. The viewer’s gaze moves from the kneeling Mary Magdalene to the centurion Longinus who, having witnessed “the earthquake, and all that was happening,” is struck with awe and fear, prompting his confession: “Truly, this was the Son of God” (27:54). The diagonal then carries onward to the swooning Virgin, overcome with grief, before coming to rest on the distant silhouette of Jerusalem. Through this carefully structured sequence, Veronese transforms the biblical account into a visual journey from earthly shock and recognition to spiritual revelation.

Above the scene, the sky darkens beneath heavy clouds, recalling the three hours of darkness described by the Evangelist: “Now from the sixth hour there was darkness over all the land unto the ninth hour” (27:45). In this way, Veronese translates Matthew’s Gospel into a carefully orchestrated sequence of visual events, where resurrection, fear, and revelation unfold simultaneously within a single, emotionally charged image.

Particularly striking is the inclusion of the resurrected dead emerging from the tomb—an iconographic motif rarely given such prominence in 16th-century representations of the Crucifixion. In the context of plague-stricken Venice, this unusual detail would have carried special resonance. The shattered grave and rising figure evoke the fragility of human life and the specter of mortality that had so recently haunted the city. Yet they also proclaim a message of hope. Rather than presenting the Crucifixion solely as a scene of suffering and loss, Veronese frames it as a meditation on redemption and the promise of life beyond death.

Four Angels Bearing the Instruments of the Passion

Since the 17th century, the canvases depicting the Four Angels Bearing the Instruments of the Passion have been attributed to Veronese’s son, Carletto Caliari. Early descriptions of San Nicolò della Lattuga record them as part of the decorative ensemble surrounding the high altar, adorning the monumental stone framework created to house Titian’s altarpiece. Arranged on two piers, they were paired with Paolo Veronese’s Prophets Isaiah and Ezekiel, now in the collection of the Fondazione Giorgio Cini, and with two sibyls by Jacopo Palma il Giovane, now lost. Rising to a height of at least twenty feet, the entire structure must have ranked among the most imposing and visually spectacular altar ensembles in Venice.

Each canvas features a youthful angel presenting objects associated with the Passion. Shown either nude or clad in red or green tunics, the angels are paired with distinct groups of symbolic instruments that recall key moments of Christ’s suffering. In the first canvas, an angel appears to fasten a rope around the column of the Flagellation and is accompanied by an iron gauntlet, the rooster, the ladder, and the spear of Longinus. In the second, an angel displays the Veil of Veronica alongside scourges and ropes, the reed bearing the sponge, and the dice cast for Christ’s garments. The third putto appears among Christ’s seamless robe, a hammer, pincers, and nails, while the fourth presents a torch and the crown of thorns together with Pontius Pilate’s basin and water pitcher.

Viewed within the wider context of the presbytery, these paintings functioned as visual counterparts to the larger narrative scenes. By isolating the instruments of the Passion and presenting them as devotional emblems, they distilled the story of Christ’s suffering into a series of potent symbols readily recognizable to worshippers. Together with Veronese’s Crucifixion and the other paintings that adorned the presbytery—including the Last Supper, Christ before Pilate, the Baptism of Christ, and the Temptation of Christ—they formed part of a carefully orchestrated decorative program centered on Christ’s earthly ministry, Passion, and the promise of redemption.

Close examination of the canvases has revealed localized losses of tension in the canvas supports, resulting in noticeable deformations. The painted surfaces are obscured by markedly discolored varnish layers whose yellowed appearance compromises the original chromatic balance and tonal legibility of the compositions. Numerous areas of pictorial integration, many of which have undergone significant chromatic alteration over time, are also visible across the surfaces.

The conservation treatment will begin with the gradual removal of degraded varnishes, altered retouchings, overpaint, and any underlying fills that are no longer considered appropriate. Once cleaning has been completed, areas of paint loss and abrasion will be filled where necessary, with particular attention given to matching the texture and surface characteristics of the surrounding paint layers. The intervention will conclude with pictorial reintegration using conservation-grade retouching materials selected for their stability and reversibility, followed by the application of a final protective varnish layer.

Paolo Veronese (1528 – 1588)
Crucifixion
1582, oil on canvas
285 x 447 cm

Carletto Calliari (1570 – 1596)
Four Angels Bearing the Instruments of the Passion
1582, oil on canvas
295 x 63 cm

Cope, Maurice E. The Venetian Chapel of the Sacrament in the Sixteenth Century. New York and London: Garland Publishing, Inc., 1979, pp. 168-170

Moschini Marconi, Sandra. Gallerie dell’Accademia di Venezia. Opere d’arte del secolo XVI. Rome: Istituto Poligrafico dello Stato, 1962, pp. 78 no 130, 89-90 no 142

Lauber, Rosella. Veronese e un magnifico “cantico” di pitture, inno alla salvezza. In Paolo Veronese. Cristo davanti a Pilato. Rome: Camera dei deputati, 2025, pp. 21-50

Pignatti, Terisio and Filippo Pedrocco. Veronese, 2 vols. Milan: Electa, 1995, vol. II, pp. 410-417

Rosand, David. Paolo Veronese. Frank, E. Mary (ed.). London-Turnhout: Harvey Miller Publisher, 2023, pp. 317-324

Ruggeri Augusti, Adriana. “La chiesa di San Nicolò della Lattuga.” Quaderni della Soprintendenza ai Beni Artistici e Storici di Venezia, 15 (1988): 145-147, 163-165

Zorzi, Alvise. Venezia scomparsa, 2 vols. Milan: Electa, 1972, vol. II, pp. 377-379